Barth and Schleiermacher
The German preacher and philosopher Friedrich Daniel Ernst Schleiermacher is often called the leading
19th-century theologian of the Protestant church.
Schleiermacher was born on November 21, 1768, in Breslau, Lower Silesia (now Wroclaw, Poland).
Despite his being the son of a Reformed clergyman, Schleiermacher studied under the Moravian
Brethren (Herrnhuters), gaining from them an appreciation for the Latin and Greek classics and a
strong sense of religious life. He found the teaching of the Herrnhuters too restrictive, however,
because the faculty refused to lecture on current intellectual trends. In 1787 he entered the University
of Halle, where he studied the philosophies of Aristotle and Immanuel
Kant. After his ordination in
1794 he accepted a position as a Reformed preacher in Berlin. There he mingled with German romantic
philosophers, became a friend of Friedrich von Schlegel, and began a translation of the works of
Plato. Apart from a period when he was professor of theology at Halle (1804-07),
most of his life from his ordination in 1794 until his death was spent as a preacher and teacher in Berlin.
From 1810 he was professor of theology at the newly founded university there.
Schleiermacher's first major work, On Religion: Speeches to Its Cultured Despisers (1799; Eng. trans., 1893), defended religion against its Enlightenment critics. Religion, he argued, was not a philosophy, nor abstract metaphysical thought, nor natural science, nor adherence to dogmatic formulae, but the "sense and taste for the infinite" consisting primarily in feeling; belief and action are secondary. Knowledge of the soul and knowledge of God are inseparable—a concept that had been presented more than 1000 years earlier by St. Augustine. His thought thus has a subjective focus, but it should not on that account be deemed sheer "subjectivism." Schleiermacher's careful analysis of religious feelings always has in view, at least by implication, the infinite and eternal reality to which these feelings are responses. The Speeches are sometimes held to be pantheist in tone, but he did not identify the world with the "infinite and eternal." Rather, he held that it is always in and through one's experience of the whole interconnecting realm of the finite that there comes a sense of dependence upon the infinite ground of all things.
In his most important work, The Christian Faith (1821; Eng. trans. of 2d ed., 1928), Schleiermacher specified religious feeling as the "feeling of absolute dependence." Correlated with the feeling of absolute dependence is a consciousness or intuition of God. Human blessedness, he taught, consists in the strengthening of the God-consciousness, and sin is the obscuring of this consciousness. Jesus Christ shared the humanity of all human beings but was unique in the strength and constancy of his God-consciousness, and his redeeming work consists in the impartation of his God-consciousness to the believer. He was not afraid to call his theology "mystical," centered as it was upon the personal communion of the believer with the wholly God-conscious Christ. His other writings include The Soliloquies (1800; trans. 1926), Christmas Eve (1806; trans. 1890), and Brief Outline of the Study of Theology (1811; trans. 1850).
Schleiermacher has been accused of making religion invulnerable at the expense of turning it into a purely subjective experience, but this criticism is contested on the grounds that it misinterprets the term feeling. The influential neoorthodox movement of early-20th-century theology, particularly as represented by Karl Barth, developed partly in reaction to Schleiermacher's influence, stating that Schleiermacher led the great defection whereby liberal theology focused on human potentiality and religiosity at the expense of God's own reality, majesty, and grace. Barth himself, however, retained a wistful admiration for Schleiermacher, eventually speculating that "all might not be lost" with him, especially if we await a theology "predominantly and decisively of the Holy Spirit."
1996 Grolier Multimedia Encyclopedia, Copyright 1996 Grolier Interactive, Inc.
Microsoft Encarta 98 Encyclopedia, Copyright 1993-1997 Microsoft Corporation.
The Blackwell Encyclopedia of Modern Christian Thought, ed. Alister E. McGrath, Copyright 1993 Blackwell Publishers Ltd.